DLJ Names Top Internet Finance Picks
By Cindy Christ
Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette Securities started coverage of
the Internet financial services industry Wednesday, naming
E*Trade Group its "Top Pick" with a 12-month price target of
$31.
Shares in E*Trade (EGRP) vaulted more than 14 percent on the
call, closing up $2.38 at $19.25.
"E*Trade is the fourth largest online broker in terms of
customer assets, third largest in terms of active accounts,
and second largest as measured by number of trades executed
per day," analyst Richard Zandi wrote in a research alert.
"We believe that dire outcomes are already priced into the
stock and view current levels as an excellent buying
opportunity," Zandi added.
DLJ also launched coverage of rivals TD Waterhouse and
Ameritrade and market maker Knight Trading Group with "buy"
ratings.
Stocks in the e-finance sector have had a rough year so far,
as rising interest rates pummeled trading volume as well as
major market averages. But while the Nasdaq has rebounded from
its recent dive, shares in most Internet brokers still trade
just above 52-week lows.
TD Waterhouse, the nation's No. 4 online broker based on
accounts, advanced on the upgrade despite cautious remarks
about its growth rate.
"TD Waterhouse targets the upper middle class online investor.
Given its business model and larger size, we expect TWE to
grow at a slower pace than its rivals," Zandi said.
Shares in TD Waterhouse (TWE) jumped 3.5 percent to $18.31,
still well below DLJ's 12-month price target of $31.
Zandi put a $19 price target on Ameritrade (AMTD), which added
$0.75, or 6 percent, to $13.31.
Market maker Knight (NITE) leaped $2.12, or 7 percent, to
$32.38.
Jersey City, N.J.-based Knight is the leader in its space
behind Schwab Capital Markets, the market maker arm of top
discount broker Charles Schwab.
"We believe NITE represents one of the most exciting ideas in
the Internet financial services space," Zandi said. "NITE's
success derives from the superior execution it provides retail
investors."
Shares in Knight plunged more than 17 percent during the last
two sessions in the wake of Merrill Lynch's $915 million
acquisition of No. 3 market maker Herzog, Heine & Geduld.
Investors unloaded Knight shares in droves on concerns it
would lose Merrill's business and on fears the combination
would threaten Knight's No. 1 market position.
With Merrill generating just 0.8 percent of its total
revenues, Knight said in a statement yesterday the deal would
have limited impact on its business.
In addition, Merrill later confirmed its intent to maintain
order flows to Knight, leading some analysts to view the deal
as a boon for the wholesale stock dealer.
"While the increased liquidity of combining two major market
makers could be attractive to the institutional market, we
believe that the potential gains in market share will be
offset by Herzog's loss of neutrality, an important criteria
for large order flow providers like E*Trade," said Robertson
Stephens Senior eFinance Analyst Scott Appleby in a research
note to clients.
"We believe the merger actually could create an opportunity
for NITE to gain trading volume from the online and discount
brokers who compete directly with Merrill," Appleby added.
Robertson Stephens, which also rates Knight a "buy," has set a
price target in the range of $70 to $80 for the market maker.
Market making is a highly profitable practice that maintains
order balance between buyers and sellers of Nasdaq stocks.
Intermediaries called "specialists" perform a similar role for
issues traded on the New York Stock Exchange.
Unlike most traders, market makers are privy to supply and
demand information for a given security, an advantage that can
translate into huge profits from buying and selling stocks in
their own accounts.
Although experts have warned that electronic trading networks
called ECNs would render market makers obsolete, Merrill's
decision to shell out nearly a $1 billion to gain a dominant
role in the space confirms the business is here to stay.
It also may portend similar moves by other Wall Street titans
in the weeks ahead, upping Knight's appeal as the only
takeover target left.